7 Questions and Answers about Presentence Investigations

For defendants in federal cases, an important part of the criminal sentencing process is the presentence investigation. The investigation becomes a report that helps the legal system determine anything from the length of a sentence to the facility where the sentence is served.

Who goes through a presentence investigation?

Anyone who enters a guilty plea or is convicted of a federal crime in a trial will be subject to a presentence investigation.

What is the purpose of a presentence investigation?

The purpose is to prepare a thorough report on the defendant and the circumstances surrounding the conviction. The judge and other people within the legal system then use the report to decide on the sentencing details.

Who conducts the investigation?

A probation officer from the U.S. Probation and Pretrial Services System conducts the investigation. They conduct the interview as a third party not connected with the defense or the prosecution.

What does a presentence investigation cover?

The initial meeting with the probation officer will generally consist of an interview with the defendant to go over the following information:

  • Family history
  • Community ties
  • Education background
  • Employment history
  • Physical health
  • Mental and emotional health
  • History of substance abuse
  • Financial condition
  • Willingness to accept responsibility for his or her offense(s)

Additionally, the probation officer will seek information from other sources. According to the U.S. Courts website, this may include the prosecutor, law enforcement agents, victims, mental health and substance abuse treatment providers, and the defendant’s family members, associates, and employer. The officer will also review documents like trial transcripts, investigative reports from other law enforcement agencies, criminal history records, counseling and substance abuse treatment records, and scholastic records.

How should I prepare for a presentence investigation?

It’s important to take the presentence investigation seriously. The report created by the probation officer will be used for more than sentencing. The probation office will also refer to the report after your sentence to assess the risks you may pose and to determine specific rules for your post-release supervision.

The best way to prepare is to counsel with an experienced defense lawyer to go over the process, determine a strategy, and make sure you have all the correct details and information. Whether you purposely or accidentally give incorrect information during your interview, you will be held accountable. Keep in mind that trying to conceal information that may make you look bad could end up causing more issues later when the parole officer interviews other people and gathers official records with your information.

Does the PSI affect which facility I am sent to?

The presentence investigation report helps the Bureau of Prisons designate which institutions may be appropriate for you. This includes consideration for which institutions have prison programs that will be beneficial or necessary.

Can a defense lawyer help with my presentence investigation?

Though the presentence investigation is handled by a probation officer, the report is disclosed to the defendant, the defense attorney, and the prosecutor before sentencing. At that time, each party has the chance to comment and request changes. That is handled through a formal process established by the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure.

This period between the investigation and sentencing can be crucial for making objections to the report and getting a fair sentence. The expert legal team at Brown, Bradshaw & Moffat can help you navigate the details of this process and get the best result.

Contact us today at (801) 532-5297 for a free consultation. We are ready to fight for your rights.

More Articles

5 Quick Facts about the Utah Medical Cannabis Act
In Utah, the Medical Cannabis Act allows individuals to acquire, use, and sell cannabis legally for certain medical conditions. While it’s legal to use cannabis under this act, there are still plenty of details within the law that may affect those who have a legal right to use cannabis in the state.
Read More →
Most Common Crimes College Students Commit in Utah
Education is a big deal in Utah. In the fall semester of 2024, the number of college students throughout the state was just over 207,000. That’s close to the population of Salt Lake City. Of course, some of those people will commit a crime at some point in their college career. Here are some of the most common crimes college students commit in Utah.
Read More →
law office in Utah
What is Considered Reckless Driving in Utah?
Reckless driving in Utah comes with serious consequences that go beyond the time you may serve behind bars. In 2024, there were 281 fatalities on Utah roads. That’s up from 279 in 2023. Those numbers represent real people with real families, and many of them would still be alive if it weren’t for poor decision-making behind the wheel.Whether or not someone gets hurt, reckless driving is a crime in Utah, and it may lead to time behind bars.
Read More →

Defend your case with the best criminal defense attorneys in Utah

Get a confidential case evaluation

Our office will contact you as soon as possible to arrange for you to discuss the facts of your case with an experienced criminal defense attorney in Salt Lake City, Utah.​ The use of this form for communication with our personnel does not establish an attorney-client relationship.